Comparing Antidepressants How do newer antidepressants compare in depression?
Archives for April 2016
Upside: The New Science of Post-Traumatic Growth
Upside: The New Science of Post-Traumatic Growth
“I’m reading a book about post-traumatic growth,” I told a friend who had suffered significant health-related trauma.
“Is that when post-traumatic stress grows worse over time?” she asked, worried.
Not at all, I told her, though I understood where she was coming from. It’s not easy to wrap one’s mind around the concept of an upside to trauma. But post-traumatic growth, a fledgling field of research, refers to positive changes that many people experience in the aftermath of traumatic events.
The term post-traumatic growth was coined by Richard Tedeschi and Lawrence Calhoun of the University of North Carolina, Charlotte. In 1996, Tedeschi and Calhoun published a psychological measurement tool called the Posttraumatic Growth Inventory, but the concept has been around for all of recorded history. In Upside: The New Science of Post-Traumatic Growth, journalist Jim Rendon points out that a traumatic incident, a passage through darkness, and ultimate growth are all part of mythology’s archetypal story. He cites Man’s Search for Meaning, published in 1946, in which Viktor Frankl explains what he came to understand about trauma and suffering while in a Nazi concentration camp. He reminds us of a 1936 story about a young boy who saw his parents murdered and vowed to spend his life fighting crime. That boy, of course, was Bruce Wayne, and his crime-fighting alter-ego was Batman.
So post-traumatic growth, by any name, is nothing new, and psychologists are finally taking a good, hard look at it. And while nobody suggests that trauma is a good thing, that it’s easily moved through, or that we would all be better off with some trauma in our lives (not that we have a choice), Rendon looks at what psychologists have learned about how people grow and even thrive in the aftermath of traumatic experiences.
Post-traumatic growth, Rendon writes, can manifest in many different ways. It can be a person feeling that life has more meaning and that they are closer to their loved ones, or it can be a life-altering change that sends them, as Rendon puts it, “on career and life paths they never would have considered before.” The book offers stories of people suffering all manner of almost incomprehensible traumas — a parachute that doesn’t open, a child killed by a stray bullet, a grenade explosion, a fall in front of an oncoming train — to illustrate what researchers have learned about post-traumatic growth.
Perhaps surprisingly, Rendon finds that people who experience post-traumatic growth are not outliers, either.
“In study after study, research shows that about half or more of trauma survivors report positive change as a result of their experience,” Rendon writes. “…Every time I talk to one of these people in my reporting — someone who has totally altered his life, his sense of self, someone who says he is thankful for what most of us would consider a terrible tragedy — I am thrilled and amazed,” he continues. “What an exceptional person, I think. And then I remember all of the others who have told me similar stories. This kind of miraculous transformation, it turns out, is hardly unusual. The potential for such inspiring change lives inside most people.”
In each chapter, Rendon uses stories and research to explore things like the importance of deliberate rumination, the role of social support, the power of talking or writing about your experience, where optimism fits in, how faith helps, and creativity.
Still, the people in the book don’t spring from their hospital beds full of hope and optimism. They move through anger, despair, depression — everything you would expect under the circumstances. But ultimately, they find their way to new careers that will help others, new communities, better relationships, deeper faith, creative breakthroughs. (The story of the Tutu Project, which you may have seen online, is in here. The series of photographs of Bob Carey in a pink tutu is now a successful fundraiser to help women with breast cancer, but it started as a way for Carey to deal with trauma when his wife, Linda, was diagnosed.) Each horrendous tale concludes not with pie-in-the-sky happily ever after, but with solid, sustainable, realistic transformation.
Before she fell in front of an oncoming train as the result of an overenthusiastic hug (the unfortunate hugger was killed), Mariam Davies lived a life of partying and dead-end jobs. After the accident — and a predictable period of anger and depression — Davies went on to become a therapist, providing low-cost counseling in her South London neighborhood. Although she can walk, she’ll never run again, and she has to wear a colostomy bag.
“I still get down about things,” she says. “I still get upset that I have to wear crap knickers that aren’t sexy because they have to hold my bag in. This is horrible, I hate it. But it’s not the end of the world.” In fact, Davies says that before the accident she knew something had to change. And after the accident she remembers waking up in her hospital bed, “having a really powerful sense that this is what I’ve been waiting for.”
Davies’s is only one of many moving, inspiring, and enlightening stories in the book, and each person changes and grows in individual ways, although helping others is a recurring theme. Upside is a well-researched, well organized, informative, and eminently readable introduction to the science behind something we’ve all been aware of on some level, but haven’t before put a name to.
Sophia Dembling is author of Introverts in Love: The Quiet Way to Happily Ever After.
Upside: The New Science of Post-Traumatic Growth
Touchstone, August 2015
Hardcover, 288 pages
$26
Mindfulness Training May Ease PTSD
Mindfulness Training May Ease PTSD
Study of war veterans shows the therapy triggers brain changes that seem to help manage thoughts, memories
Source: HealthDay
Mindfulness Training Leads to Brain Changes in Vets With PTSD
Mindfulness Training Leads to Brain Changes in Vets With PTSD
New research shows the promise of mindfulness training for helping veterans with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) manage the memories and thoughts that keep playing over and over in their minds in an endless loop.
Even more surprising, according to researchers, is that the veterans’ brains actually changed in ways that may help them find their own off switch for that endless loop.
The findings, published in Depression and Anxiety by a team from the University of Michigan Medical School and VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System, come from a study of 23 veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan.
All of the vets got some form of group therapy. After four months of weekly sessions, many reported that their PTSD symptoms eased up.
But only in those who got mindfulness training — a mind-body technique that focuses on in-the-moment attention and awareness — did the researchers see the brain changes.
The changes showed up on functional MRI, or fMRI, brain scans that can visualize brain activity as different areas of the brain “talk” to one another through networks of connections between brain cells, according to the researchers.
Before the mindfulness training, when the veterans were resting quietly, their brains had extra activity in regions involved in responding to threats or other outside problems. This is a sign of that endless loop of hypervigilance often seen in PTSD, researchers noted.
But after learning mindfulness, they developed stronger connections between two other brain networks: The one involved in our inner, sometimes meandering, thoughts, and the one involved in shifting and directing attention.
“The brain findings suggest that mindfulness training may have helped the veterans develop more capacity to shift their attention and get themselves out of being ‘stuck’ in painful cycles of thoughts,” said Anthony King, Ph.D., a University of Michigan Department of Psychiatry researcher who led the new study in collaboration with VA psychologists.
“We’re hopeful that this brain signature shows the potential of mindfulness to be helpful for managing PTSD for people who might initially decline therapy involving trauma processing,” he said. “We hope it may provide emotional regulation skills to help bring them to a place where they feel better able to process their traumas.”
In all, 14 of the veterans finished the mindfulness sessions and completed follow-up fMRI scans, and nine finished the comparison sessions and had scans. The small size of the group means the new results are only the start of an exploration of this issue, King said.
Source: University of Michigan Medical School and VA Ann Arbor
PTSD May Stiffen Veterans’ Arteries, Boosting Heart Risks
PTSD May Stiffen Veterans’ Arteries, Boosting Heart Risks
Reducing stress may help blood vessels function normally, expert says
Source: HealthDay
Transgender Veterans Face High Risk of Mental Health Problems
Transgender Veterans Face High Risk of Mental Health Problems
Among military veterans who identify as transgender, nearly 50 percent have been hospitalized due to a suicide attempt or suicidal thoughts, and 90 percent have at least one mental health diagnosis, such as depression or posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), according to a new study whose findings will be presented at The Endocrine Society’s 98th annual meeting in Boston.
The military population, including both active members and veterans, has a fourfold higher rate of gender dysphoria compared to the general U.S. population. Formerly known as gender identity disorder, gender dysphoria is the experience of significant distress associated with nonconformity to one’s birth gender.
“As more of our active military returns from deployment and transitions to veteran status, the health care system will be faced with treating more transgender veterans who have mental health issues,” said principal investigator Marissa Grotzke, M.D., an endocrinologist at Salt Lake City Veterans Affairs Medical Center (VAMC), Salt Lake City.
It is already known that non-veterans with gender dysphoria have distinct health care concerns and much higher rates of mental health problems, such as depression, anxiety, and suicidal thoughts. Previous studies have also shown that military veterans suffer from higher rates of mental health disorders as well, including PTSD and depression. Less is known, however, about the double mental health impact of veterans with gender dysphoria.
By examining 2014-2015 medical records at Salt Lake City VAMC, Grotzke and her team found 39 patients who had a diagnosis of gender dysphoria. Eight transgender patients were transitioning from female to male, and the other 39 were male-to-female. They included both combat and noncombat veterans and ranged in age from 21 to 68 years.
The researchers then looked for mental health conditions that coexisted with the gender dysphoria. They found that PTSD was the most commonly identified mental health diagnosis, affecting 46 percent of these veterans, followed by depression in 41 percent. Tobacco use occurred in one-third, and anxiety was present in 15 percent. Nine patients (23 percent) had other substance abuse, bipolar disorder, or schizotypal personality disorder.
Eighteen patients (46 percent) carried two or more mental health diagnoses, according to the researchers. Only four patients (10 percent) with gender dysphoria had no additional mental health problem.
“These findings highlight the need to improve the quality of care for our transgender veterans,” Grotzke said.
To address these issues, the Salt Lake City VAMC formed a multidisciplinary gender dysphoria team composed of an endocrinologist, mental health professional, pharmacist, speech therapist and vocational rehabilitation providers. Team members meet together twice a month to discuss patients and treatment plans, which Grotzke said already has been “very beneficial” for patients.
There are most likely several reasons behind the increased rates of mental health disorders found in transgender veterans. Grotzke said that traumatic brain injuries sustained in combat, military sexual abuse, and stigma related to gender struggles are common in this population.
Source: The Endocrine Society
PTSD May Hike Risk of Heart Attack, Stroke
PTSD May Hike Risk of Heart Attack, Stroke
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) may reduce the ability of blood vessels to fully dilate, which may raise the risk of heart attack and stroke, according to a new study of veterans published in the Journal of the American Heart Association.
The findings showed that the blood vessels of veterans with PTSD were less reactive and did not expand normally in response to stimuli compared to veterans without PTSD. Less reactive blood vessels are associated with the development of heart disease and other serious conditions.
“Traditional risk factors such as high blood pressure, diabetes, high cholesterol and smoking, have not fully explained why people with PTSD seem to be at higher heart disease risk. Our study suggests that chronic stress may directly impact the health of the blood vessels,” said lead author Marlene Grenon, M.D., associate professor of surgery at the University of California San Francisco and vascular surgeon at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center San Francisco /Veterans Affairs Medical Center-Surgical Services.
For the study, the researchers used a standard test known as flow-mediated dilation (FMD) to gauge how well an artery in the arm relaxes and expands in response to the squeezing of a blood-pressure cuff.
They compared the FMD scores of 67 veterans (average age 68, 99 percent male) with PTSD and 147 veterans (average age 69, 91 percent male) without PTSD. The presence of PTSD was defined as a score of 40 or higher on the PTSD Symptom Checklist.
The findings showed that veterans with PTSD had significantly lower FMD scores; that is, their blood vessels expanded only 5.8 percent compared to 7.5 percent among non-PTSD veterans, indicating a less-healthy response in the lining of their blood vessels.
Veterans with PTSD were more likely to be male and to have a diagnosis of depression, but less likely to be taking ace-inhibitors or beta-blockers to treat high blood pressure. Aside from PTSD, lower scores on the FMD test were also linked to increasing age, worse renal function, and high blood pressure.
After adjusting for differences in age and the presence of other conditions and treatments, PTSD itself was still very strongly linked to reduced blood vessel dilation.
While the current study only included veterans, PTSD can also occur in non-veterans as a result of experiencing or observing a terrifying event, such as warfare, natural disasters, sexual assault, other physical violence, or trauma.
People with PTSD may experience prolonged anxiety, flashbacks, nightmares and many other severe symptoms. The disorder is estimated to affect 7.7 million people in the United States according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services National Institutes of Health.
Source: American Heart Association
Heart and cardiovascular system photo by shutterstock.
Vets Receive Care for Sub-Clinical PTSD
Vets Receive Care for Sub-Clinical PTSD
A new study reports that veterans who fall just below the threshold for a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) respond to a psychotherapy regimen better than those with full PTSD.
Investigators believe the study highlights the need to recognize veterans suffering from an overlooked condition called subclinical PTSD.
Researchers from the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences at the Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) discuss their findings in the Journal of Anxiety Disorders.
“The study shows not only that we can treat those experiencing subclinical presentations of PTSD, but also that those with subclinical PTSD may actually respond better to treatment than those with more severe forms of the disease,” says MUSC investigator Kristina Korte, Ph.D.
Researchers explain that just like patients with full PTSD, those with subclinical PTSD have experienced a traumatic event and are regularly re-experiencing it, often in nightmares or flashbacks.
Patients with full PTSD also experience hyperarousal (i.e., they are easily startled) and avoid reminders of the event, for example by withdrawing from social interaction or turning to substance abuse.
In addition re-experiencing the event, patients with subclinical PTSD may exhibit either hyperarousal or avoidance, but not both.
Psychologists began noticing this pattern more frequently in the nineties in veterans returning from the first Iraq War, and even more frequently in veterans returning from Iraq and Afghanistan in the last decade.
As researchers have learned more about these patients over time, varying and sometimes conflicting symptoms have provided an incomplete picture of the disorder and how to treat it.
The issue is complicated as those with subclinical PTSD are often excluded from clinical trials testing treatments for PTSD. That is, patients with only some symptoms of PTSD commonly aren’t included in the healthy control group or in the group with full PTSD.
As a result, there is still no standard psychotherapy for treating subclinical PTSD as there is for full PTSD.
According, the researchers devised an intuitive approach — Why not treat subclinical PTSD patients with one of the standard evidence-based psychotherapy tools already being used in PTSD patients?
To do this, they enrolled 200 patients with combat-related PTSD symptoms, identifying those with either subclinical or full PTSD.
For eight weeks, patients received intensive weekly sessions of behavioral activation and therapeutic exposure therapy, designed to lessen their PTSD symptoms by helping them safely re-experience and resolve elements of the original trauma.
Psychologists rated the patients’ PTSD symptoms and had patients rate their own symptoms before, during, and after the eight weeks.
The results were encouraging. Those with subclinical or full PTSD each experienced a real drop in PTSD symptoms after treatment. The striking result was in how much those symptoms dropped: 29 percent in those with subclinical PTSD as compared to 14 percent with full PTSD.
It may seem obvious that patients with a less severe form of PTSD would respond better to standard psychotherapy, but the implications for treatment are far-reaching.
That is, PTSD symptoms often worsen over time; as they do, treatments become less effective at reducing symptoms. In this context, subclinical PTSD could be seen as “early-stage” PTSD, in that treatment might be more effective when the disorder is caught early.
Researchers hope these early studies can move beyond men in combat to civilians of both sexes.
“It is our hope that providing treatment for subclinical PTSD could have a significant impact on the cost-effectiveness of treating this common disorder,” says Korte.
“It could lead to the prevention of more intractable forms of PTSD that can occur when subclinical PTSD goes untreated.”
Source: Medical University of South Carolina/EurekAlert
Veteran in counseling photo by shutterstock.